The mine, the lifeless fish, the villagers and their protests

The Minister for Water has not revealed the federal government’s personal laboratory studies on the lifeless fish and water high quality. An unbiased knowledgeable studied these studies and highlighted an absence of knowledge and inadequate evaluation, akin to decide on the ban troublesome to advise.

QMM insists the studies ought to be launched, regardless of their scientific shortcomings. Campaigners imagine the studies could be used to exonerate QMM, while being a travesty of Rio Tinto’s worldwide requirements on water and tailings administration.


It’s unclear whether or not additional official testing has been carried out, leaving the reason for fish kills open to continued hearsay and hypothesis. In the meantime, an settlement made this week with villagers to start fishing once more, with out strong scientific knowledge to help the choice, locations the chance of any damaging penalties within the palms of native fisherfolk.

Rural villagers regularly carry the unseen prices of the mine. In line with a brand new examine by Publish What You Pay Madagascar (PWYP MG 2022), the mine affected communities have misplaced nearly half the worth of their earlier livelihoods, and endured years of diminished fish shares, degraded pure sources and well being issues because of QMM’s affect.

Their complaints have met with unsatisfactory response from QMM, who villagers maintain accountable for a decade of failures to deal with the social disaster brought on by the mine.

Some 3,500 villagers mandated the protest leaders to symbolize their wants and claims.  When questioned by police about who had advised them to arrange highway blocks, villagers replied “my abdomen!”

Regardless of the hardship endured by these villagers, QMM are reported to have urged their sub-contractors and employees to return out on the streets in counter-demonstrations. Locals have been seen waving costly banners that proclaimed “allow us to work” – even when the protestors had already dismantled their highway block. 


QMM has denied involvement in these occasions. A spokesperson advised The Ecologist: “The gathering talked about was not organised by QMM. It was a peaceable rally by members of the group…some workers and suppliers selected to hitch the assembly as is their proper.”

On the similar time, campaigners declare that QMM has offered itself as a sufferer of extortion, characterising village protestors as a small, violent group with no reliable claims.

Vilifying the agricultural poor can be not new.  When questions have been raised at Rio Tinto’s Australian AGM to recommend QMM be held accountable for the disaster in Anosy, the corporate response was in charge rural populations for the issues within the area.

The Australian Centre for Company Duty (ACCR), which despatched researchers to attended the AGM, instantly issued a press release saying: “QMM is at risk of dropping its social licence to function. The scenario in Madagascar seems to symbolize one other failure ensuing from Rio Tinto’s degraded social efficiency perform.”

Options have been gradual and elusive to emerge, probably affected by unseen complexities of a political and financial nature. QMM is in the course of negotiating its new lease settlement with the Malagasy Authorities, and the Malagasy elections are additionally on the horizon for 2023.


Poor communications, depleted belief within the mining firm, and QMM’s quasi-state energy within the area are additionally a part of the social and political dynamic, affecting relationships and perceptions.

For instance, Malagasy media reported that QMM had threatened to leave Madagascar, and townsfolk in Ft Dauphin report that on two events they’ve ready for the electrical energy to be minimize offs as QMM management the native vitality provide.

Nevertheless, the settlement hammered out final week-end has drawn a line underneath the speedy tensions, stopping the usage of army pressure on the one facet and highway blocks on the opposite. It stays to be seen if the ultimate settlement between QMM and the villagers will maintain and whether or not calls for for treatment and compensation can be met in full.

Rio Tinto has promised to “reset” the corporate after the Juukan Gorge debacle and the damning report of its inside tradition of racism, sexism and bullying.

Relations with conventional house owners are a precedence, in accordance with the board’s deal with to shareholders at this yr’s London AGM, the place a number of questions about Madagascar have been raised.

In Madagascar, the QMM operation stands out for instance of how to not do group relations.  

Proper of Reply

A spokesperson for Rio Tinto QMM advised The Ecologist: “For a number of weeks, there was a rise in group unrest which has risked the security and safety of our folks and members of the host group.

“The choice to curtail operations and preserve solely important companies, together with electrical energy to the native communities, was taken till the security and safety place had improved. Our topmost precedence is all the time the security and wellbeing of our folks and host communities.

“Our focus has been on discovering lasting options in order that QMM can return to regular operations in a sustainable method.

“We’re grateful for the help supplied to us by native authorities, the Governor of the Anosy area, the communities and our folks, over latest weeks and we are going to proceed to work with them and the native communities as we implement the settlement reached.”

The assertion provides: “QMM dismisses the direct cause-and-effect hyperlink between the invention of those lifeless fish and its actions. Opposite to the claims within the article, now we have by no means threatened to shut the operation down or to cease manufacturing of electrical energy for our native communities.”

This Writer

Yvonne Orengo is an unbiased communications marketing consultant and director of the Andrew Lees Trust (ALT UK) a British charity arrange following the dying of its namesake in 1994. ALT UK is working with Publish What You Pay (PWYP) Madagascar and worldwide campaigners to analysis and advocate concerning the impacts of the QMM mine on rural communities in Anosy area, Southern Madagascar. Yvonne lived and labored in southern Madagascar to develop social and environmental programmes and has adopted the evolution of the Rio Tinto/QMM mine for over twenty-six years.


Leave a Reply