Study questions whether FMCSA’s ELD mandate for truckers ‘has improved safety’

East Lansing, MI — The Federal Motor Provider Security Administration’s mandate on using electronic logging devices to file industrial motorized vehicle driver hours of service “didn’t instantly obtain its purpose of decreasing accidents,” and could also be linked to will increase in unsafe driving behaviors and crashes, outcomes of a latest research recommend.

The mandate took impact in December 2017. On April 1, 2018, inspectors have been permitted to start putting CMV drivers out of service for working with out ELDs, that are used instead of guide paper logs to trace HOS.

Researchers at Michigan State College and the College of Arkansas analyzed knowledge from about 4 million roadside inspections and all federally recordable crashes between Jan. 1, 2017, and Sept. 1, 2018. Though the mandate triggered important enchancment in driver compliance with reporting HOS, particularly amongst smaller fleets, findings present that the variety of incidents elevated after the mandate went into impact.

For unbiased owner-operators, incidents climbed 11.6%, whereas fleets using between two and 20 vans skilled a 9% enhance. The researchers additionally report a rise in violations for unsafe driver behaviors – together with dashing, frequent lane adjustments, following too carefully and arduous braking – together with the mandate.

“These outcomes name into query whether or not elevated digital monitoring has improved security on this trade,” the researchers write.

After publishing the ultimate rule in December 2015, FMCSA estimated the mandate would assist forestall 1,844 crashes, 562 accidents and 26 fatalities annually.

“Drivers have reacted in methods the FMCSA has not totally anticipated, and these behaviors ought to be accounted for because the FMCSA revisits their hours-of-service insurance policies,” Andrew Balthrop, research co-author and analysis affiliate at UA, stated in a press launch.

“Surprisingly, the variety of accidents for essentially the most affected carriers – these operators for whom the federal mandate was supposed – didn’t lower. Actually, following the implementation of the mandate, accidents amongst small carriers and unbiased owner-operators elevated, relative to giant asset-based carriers.”

ELDs record – at frequent intervals – car info equivalent to date, time, location, engine hours and miles, in addition to identification info for the motive force, car and motor service.

Proponents of the mandate contend that counting on ELDs relatively than paper logs to trace HOS improves security and effectivity. Opponents declare the rule violates drivers’ Fourth Modification rights in opposition to unreasonable search and seizure and lacks concrete proof that it will increase security.

CMV drivers should carry 4 objects as a part of the mandate:

  • A person’s guide that describes how you can function the ELD
  • A sheet itemizing step-by-step directions on producing and transferring HOS data to a licensed security official
  • A sheet that outlines ELD malfunction reporting necessities and protocol for sustaining data throughout such incidences
  • Not less than eight days’ price of clean grids to chart file of responsibility standing reviews

The research was published within the March subject of the Journal of Operations Administration.


Leave a Reply