My household gained’t help me within the face of my brother’s assaults: Ask Ellie

Reader’s Commentary Concerning a bullying brother (Feb. 21):

“I solely just lately grew to become conscious of the unique query, which might simply have been written by my ten-years-younger brother.

“My spouse, me, and my two grownup kids imagine that it’s he who’s been impolite/aggressive to me over a few years.

“He’s repeatedly challenged or criticized me publicly at any time when the chance arises.

“We stay fairly totally different lives and have very totally different political beliefs, and so on. His disagreements with me have been unlucky, however didn’t disrupt my life.

“That’s modified considerably just lately.

“Periodically, I’m requested by different members of the family to carry out a ‘public responsibility’ for the household. (I do public talking in my skilled work.)

“After our father handed away a number of years in the past, I used to be requested to present the eulogy at his funeral. Instantly after I’d completed, my brother stormed as much as me and stated loud sufficient that others might hear, that I ‘was talking for myself,’ and didn’t mirror his emotions.

“Truly, my remarks have been totally constructive and laudatory. Additionally, he might’ve ascended to the rostrum and spoken about our father, too.

“Then, on our mom’s 91st birthday with many different non-family members current, I used to be requested once more to make a public toast to our mother.

“All through it, he muttered loudly sufficient so others might hear, how ‘ridiculous and tedious’ my remarks have been.

“Final fall, after our sister contacted each of us by way of three-way texting, in search of assist in a household matter regarding our mom, I responded with constructive, supportive recommendation.

“My brother responded viciously, accusing me of unfaithful ugly motivations.

“When my spouse tried to mediate the dispute by way of electronic mail, he responded to her in a equally aggressive approach. Going after my spouse for under making an attempt to assist is unacceptable!

“This has now negatively affected my relationship with my sister and mom, whom I’d requested for assist. They’ve stated it’s between me and my brother, they don’t wish to get entangled.

“I’d settle for their view, if the problems I elevate have been consequence of my conversations solely with my brother. However since they requested me to do one thing publicly on behalf of the household, I really feel household ought to intervene.

“As a substitute, I haven’t acquired their help.

“Now, I’m most indignant at my brother as a result of he gained’t apologize to my spouse.

“I’m upset in our sister and mom as a result of they know the info and do nothing.

“However my response to this unhappy state of affairs is to withdraw utterly, or as you stated in your unique column response, I’ll ‘disengage’ from the entire ‘poisonous’ personalities, and scale back contact as a lot as potential.”

Not the Bully

Ellie:You’ve introduced your case, and nothing’s modified. Your youthful brother’s resentment of you has clearly existed for years.

Possibly the ten-year hole prevented a pure sibling relationship. There are large variations in younger folks’s influences and expectations inside a specific decade. You two have been apparently by no means shut in spirit and perspective.

In the meantime, there have been alternatives to incorporate him by asking him on to additionally categorical his ideas on his father’s life, which isn’t unusual at eulogies.

Your sister and mom repeated this neglect by having solely you talk about your mother — somebody ought to’ve linked the dots.

Your spouse’s outreach was, unwittingly, like a match to a flame, since everybody is aware of how he reacts.

I agree along with your determination to withdraw from the potential of ongoing future battle. However there’s a tragic household story right here with no complete innocents, since everybody knew the issue way back.

Ellie’s tip of the day

Grownup sibling resentments/bullying are not often a shock to the household. Empathy, dialogue, counselling, well being evaluation, all could also be useful, IF they’re tried.

Ellie Tesher is an recommendation columnist for the Star and primarily based in Toronto. Ship your relationship questions by way of electronic mail:


Conversations are opinions of our readers and are topic to the Code of Conduct. The Star doesn’t endorse these opinions.


Leave a Reply